Ziua Logo
  Nr. 4235 de luni, 19 mai 2008 
 Cauta:  
  Detalii »
English
EDITORIAL
From Middle Israel to Middle Palestine
-- Americans speak of "Middle America" and Britons of "Middle England." Bothare near mythic places that supposedly embody the authentic character of the nation. Israel, too, has its "Middle Israel," but it is very different from the place that Americans and Britons describe.
Rather than being somewhat provincial, Middle Israel is educated, bilingual or
multilingual, and extremely well connected to the wider world. It has provided
Israel with the high-tech success that it has enjoyed over the last decade. Middle
Israel is mostly secular, though it also includes the moderately religious. It is
liberal, and despises any sort of fanaticism, whether orthodox or nationalist. It is
based on a strong, legally entrenched (though never perfect) ethos of gender
equality that has typified Zionism from its start.
Middle Israel is also gay-friendly and distinctly non-xenophobic. It is mostly
Jewish, though a young Arab professional class is now coming out of the universities
and making its way - with difficulties - into the heartland of civil society. And,
lest we forget, Middle Israel is earning the money and paying the taxes that support
a wide assortment of traditionalists, fundamentalists, chauvinists, and other
extremists - Jewish and Muslim - from Gaza to Jerusalem to the West Bank.
This quiet majority is under-represented in the Knesset because its members steer
clear of political careers. It is far too large to be considered an elite. It is not
exclusively urban, and it includes people of different cultural origins. It has a
powerful common identity, shared memories, and a rich culture. It is neither
inward-looking nor atavistic.
Some Palestinians hope to become, one day, something like Middle Israel. They, too,
would like life, pragmatism, creativity, and even joy to gain the upper hand. They,
too, want moderation and modernity, if perhaps not full secularization, to prevail.
These Palestinians are Middle Israel's natural allies.
Fed by a meager diet of media reporting and some coarse think-tank buzz, European
and American friends often ask me why our universities are awash with self-hating,
anti-Israel "post-Zionists." But they are not. Post-Zionism is a much hyped phantom,
a term flourished in the mid-1990's, when it seemed that Israeli and Palestinian
leaders were building a peace process. In response, Israelis quickly developed their
own "End of History" thesis, suggesting that soon Zionism would be a thing of the
past, primarily because there would no longer be a need for any
ideologyto support what would be a normal modern state, at peace with its neighbors and with its past traumas.
Back then, historians and sociologists dug into Zionism supposed "sins" - for
example, that Israel's Arab citizens have never, to this day, enjoyed equal civil
rights. Others looked at crimes against Palestinians in the wake of our
self-defensive War of Independence. Many people denied these facts; many others
looked them in the eye. Those of us who were not post-Zionists, but liberal
Zionists, were even proud of the way our society had entered this phase of
self-inspection and self-critique.
The gravest problem for Middle Israel is the Palestinian predicament in the occupied
West Bank and in deadlocked Gaza. Our leaders, from Levy Eshkol (and much more so
Golda Meir) to Yitzhak Shamir, erred gravely in not seizing the earliest opportunity
to arrange a territorial separation and a horizon of sovereignty for the post-1967
Palestinians. They erred gravely in allowing Jewish settlers to have their way on
the Biblical mountaintops, while Middle Israel looked the other way. They erred
gravely - and this is less often recognized - in discouraging the moderate
Palestinian middle class, many of whom have quit the occupied territories, leaving
behind a generation of young, ignorant, hungry, and angry warriors.
But there is a solution to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. It is geographical: a
division of territory and a separation of homelands that involves painful but
conceivable compromises on both sides. Jerusalem will be divided, Palestinian
refugees will not return to their ancestral homes, and Jewish settlements in the
West Bank will, like their Gaza counterparts, be dismantled or (inconceivably) left
to fend for themselves.
Of course, extremists will hate it. By contrast, moderates - all moderates - will
accept it, albeit unhappily.
If the moderates win, then a "Middle Palestine" will at last rise to prominence.
Paralleling Middle Israel, though perhaps not initially befriending it or liking it
very much, this kind of Palestine will be the best news that the Middle East will
have had for a long time.
For now, we in Middle Israel must curb our own extremists and hold out for the
Palestinian moderates to prevail.
Fania Oz-Salzberger is a Senior Lecturer in History and Director of the Posen
Research Forum for Political Thought at the Faculty of Law, University of Haifa,
and Professor and Leon Liberman Chair in Modern Israel Studies at Monash
University. Among her books are Translating the Enlightenment and Israelis in
Berlin.
Copyright: Project Syndicate, 2008.
Fania Oz SALZBERGER 
A r h i v a
  God's regional urbanism plan    
  'Stained' candidates run for leadership over district councils    
  President opened Palace to visitors    
 Top afisari / comentarii 
 Prostituata "MI5" (2649 afisari)
 56 candidati patati (2365 afisari)
 Scoala de inalte apucaturi (1412 afisari)
 Puzul lui Dumnezeu (1113 afisari)
 Vali Sterian - protesatatar de tip american (1110 afisari)
 O bătrană, declarată decedată de asistenta de pe ambulanță, s-a trezit in timpul anchetei criminaliștilor (2758 afisari)
 Mercedes vine la Timisoara (2125 afisari)
 Regele Mihai I viziteaza castelul Peles dupa 60 de ani  (2098 afisari)
 Scribii lui Voronin si Smirnov angajati sa transforme Romania in sperietoare  (2025 afisari)
 Greu de... imbatranit: Veteranii Harrison Ford si Robert Redford fac capetele sa se intoarca dupa ei (1895 afisari)
Valid HTML 4.01 Transitional  Valid CSS!  This website is ACAP-enabled   
ISSN 1583-8021, © 1998-2008 ziua "ziua srl", toate drepturile rezervate. Procesare 0.01137 sec.